What We Can Do

 

Given that the PRC overseas operatives are covert, extensive and intrusive, it would be very difficult for us, average Canadian voters and citizens, to detect infiltrating maneuvers or interfering tactics and to counteract with state-level sophistication. 

 

With the PRC becoming a part of our daily reality, the best defensive mechanism that we can and should adopt, both individually and collectively, is to strengthen the democratic underpinnings of our institutions and communities by way of developing a set of “best democratic practices.”

 

The best practices may include but not limited to: 

​​

Look beyond Ethnicity and Follow the Money 

We have to bear in mind that we are dealing with a foreign power that is authoritarian and thuggish in nature, operating via their “agents of influence” here in Canada. These agents of influence do not constitute or represent the Chinese Canadian community (link to PRC vs. Chinese). Instead, they can be from any ethnic heritage or background, institution, organization or community groups.  

 

The first step, according to columnist and China expert Jonathan Manthorpe, is to look for the agents of influence “whose incomes or reputations depend on promoting Beijing’s interests in Canada’s corridor of power.” When applied to political leaders, candidates or leaders of any kind, it should not be too difficult for the public to look up their past record and/or any suspicious ties with the PRC or even with the CCP. 

 

A more thorough screening of the affiliations of such “agents of influence” or “captured elites” would be feasible to identify any potential conflicts of interest, including that of business links or personal ties that either depend too heavily on the Chinese market or embedded too deeply with any authorities in the PRC. 

 

Institutions, organizations or community groups with PRC- or CCP-linked interests are prone to self-censorship, sometimes due to fear that their actions or inactions will anger the PRC and jeopardize their financial gain. Therefore, suspected agents of influence or captured elites should also be screened for what they have done or said in the past regarding Canada-PRC relations. One key question to ask: Do they stand up for Canadian values and interests rather than trying to please or are in fear of offending the PRC, or deliberately equating the PRC with Chinese Canadian community? 

​​

Demand Openness and Transparency 

​Since most of PRC’s influence-peddling or interference would be conducted under the radar, transparency would be the best tool to reveal and expose such covert operations. 

According to Manthorpe, “Transparency is probably the best weapon. After leaving public office, politicians and senior officials could be required to maintain a public record of their positions and interests for, say, 20 years. … There is anecdotal evidence of a problem with Canadian officials and politicians, especially at the provincial and federal level, taking lucrative jobs with Chinese companies and institutions after leaving public life here. This raises questions about who they were really working for while still on the Canadian taxpayers’ ticket.” 

 

Transparency is also an effective tool available during elections. Political parties and the candidates should insist on knowing the ultimate donors of their campaign are known and traceable so as to make sure that their campaign finances are open, transparent and traceable. This is important even when donations are channelled through Canadian citizens. 

 

On the voters’ side, we should also insist on full disclosure and transparency of the campaign finances of local ridings, especially the source of donations and related expenditures of our candidates. 

​​

Publicity and Media 

The other aspect of being fully transparent is to call out malpractices. Canadian citizens, voters and candidates, as well as the campaign workers, have the responsibility to expose and report any request for suspicious dealings, shady acts or return favours. The responsibility lies particularly with the political parties and their candidates, who should take up the leadership role to make sure that their campaigns will involve no undesirable dealings or dark corner negotiations. 

 

Such transparency will also benefit them in the long term, in the case when candidates are elected to office, that they will not be coerced, blackmailed or threatened to undertake any unethical measures that would diminish Canadian interests. 

 

Working hand in hand, transparency and publicity would root out any covert and unduly operations under the table that try to avoid public or media scrutiny. 

 

This will also require everyone involved in the campaigns or political activities to exercise due diligence and to conduct themselves in good faith. This will help make sure that our election laws and regulations are faithfully followed.  

​​

To incorporate democratic values in our daily life for a free and open society 

This would include dispelling any disinformation and propaganda by opening up to information through diversified and multiple sources. It also hinges on acting out democracy in our lives, from exercising and defending the freedom of expression, of assembly, of access to information, and freedom to choose our elected officials, among others.  

 

The best defence against the interference of the PRC and their agents of influence is a free and open society that allows every Canadian to enjoy freedom, civil liberties, human rights and the rule of law. 

 

These suggestions are not exhaustive, but we will endeavor to stop any foreign power from taking advantage of our open, free and democratic system for the purpose of exploiting it contrary to Canadian interests.